| vs. Livingston competitive |
 |
| 5 | Liam Buchanan (2007-2009) |
| 4 | Colin McGlashan (1990-1992) |
| 4 | Kenny McDowall (1984-1984) |
| 3 | Albert Craig (1995-2000) |
| 3 | Gerry McCoy (1988-1989) |
| 3 | Gordon Dalziel (1984-1985) |
| 3 | Kris Doolan (2013-2018) |
| 3 | Mark Roberts (2006-2007) |
| 3 | Robert Dunn (1998-1999) |
| 3 | Ronnie Glavin (1974-1974)   |
| 3 | Steven Lawless (2012-2013) |
| 3 | Willie McGuire (1987-1988) |
| 2 | Aaron Taylor-Sinclair (2012-2012) |
| 2 | Adam Strachan (2007-2007) |
| 2 | Alan Logan (1985-1985) |
| 2 | Andy Dunlop (1983-1984) |
| 2 | Calum Campbell (1989-1991) |
| 2 | Chris Erskine (2013-2017) |
| 2 | Denis McQuade (1976-1976) |
| 2 | Gary Harkins (2009-2009) |
| 2 | Gerry Britton (2004-2004) |
| 2 | James Grady (2004-2004) |
| 2 | Jamie Mitchell (2002-2002) |
| 2 | Joe Craig (1974-1974) |
| 2 | Marc Twaddle (2008-2008) |
| 2 | Paul Cairney (2012-2012) |
| 2 | Stephen McKeown (2008-2008) |
| 2 | Steven Craig (2013-2013) |
| 1 | Aaron Muirhead (2013-2013) |
| 1 | Adrian Madaschi (2004-2004) |
| 1 | Aidan Fitzpatrick (2024-2024)  |
| 1 | Alex Burns (2003-2003) |
| 1 | Allan Russell (2007-2007) |
| 1 | Andy Anderson (1976-1976) |
| 1 | Andy Thomson (2004-2004) |
| 1 | Benny Rooney (1974-1974) |
| 1 | Brian Whittaker (1976-1976) |
| 1 | Brian Wright (1990-1990) |
| 1 | Chic Charnley (1990-1990) |
| 1 | Chris Turner (2008-2008) |
| 1 | Christie Elliott (2011-2011) |
| 1 | Conrad Balatoni (2011-2011) |
| 1 | Damon Gray (2008-2008) |
| 1 | Darren Brady (2006-2006) |
| 1 | David Lilley (2003-2003) |
| 1 | David Rowson (2009-2009) |
| 1 | Dougie Somner (1976-1976) |
| 1 | Eddie Gallagher (1987-1987) |
| 1 | Iain Jardine (1983-1983) |
| 1 | Ian Maxwell (2008-2008) |
| 1 | Ian McDonald (1988-1988) |
| 1 | James Craigen (2013-2013) |
| 1 | Jim Docherty (1983-1983) |
| 1 | Jim Kerr (1988-1988) |
| 1 | Jim Melrose (1976-1976) |
| 1 | Johnny Flood (1989-1989) |
| 1 | Kenny Milne (2003-2003) |
| 1 | Kenny Watson (1984-1984) |
| 1 | Kerr McInroy (2024-2024) |
| 1 | Lex Grant (1989-1989) |
| 1 | Pat Kelly (1988-1988) |
| 1 | Paul McKenzie (1985-1985) |
| 1 | Paul Paton (2009-2009) |
| 1 | Scott Chaplain (2007-2007) |
| 1 | Scott McLean (2000-2000) |
| 1 | Stephen McConalogue (2006-2006) |
| 1 | Stuart Bannigan (2012-2012) |
| 1 | Willie Herd (1984-1984) |
| |
| first scorer |
| last scorer |
| hat-trick |
| 3 own goals in total |
| all scorers known |
|
