| vs. Heart of Midlothian competitive |
 |
| 10 | George Smith (1954-1963)  |
| 10 | Jimmy Walker (1948-1953) |
| 9 | Sam Kennedy (1903-1908) |
| 8 | Alex Wright (1952-1961) |
| 8 | Willie Sharp (1940-1956) |
| 7 | Alex Stott (1950-1952) |
| 7 | Neil Duffy (1961-1964) |
| 7 | Neil Harris (1915-1919)  |
| 7 | Willie Newall (1940-1943) |
| 6 | Dougie Somner (1977-1979) |
| 6 | Jimmy Kinloch (1921-1927) |
| 6 | Willie O'Donnell (1945-1950) |
| 5 | Jim Melrose (1976-1979) |
| 5 | Jimmy Bone (1969-1970) |
| 5 | John Simpson (1929-1931) |
| 5 | John Wallace (1936-1938) |
| 4 | Billy Hainey (1962-1964) |
| 4 | Denis McQuade (1972-1974) |
| 4 | Frank Coulston (1967-1974) |
| 4 | Gerry Britton (1992-1993) |
| 4 | Kris Doolan (2014-2017) |
| 4 | Maurice Candlin (1942-1945) |
| 4 | Peter Bain (1934-1935) |
| 4 | Ronnie Glavin (1972-1974) |
| 4 | Tommy Ewing (1956-1964) |
| 3 | Alex McGregor (1907-1908) |
| 3 | Alex O'Hara (1978-1982) |
| 3 | Andy Kerr (1954-1954) |
| 3 | Archie McCallum (1950-1950) |
| 3 | Davie McParland (1964-1965) |
| 3 | Davie Ness (1930-1934) |
| 3 | Fred Robertson (1909-1910) |
| 3 | Jim Marshall (1911-1914) |
| 3 | Jimmy Davidson (1954-1954) |
| 3 | Joe Craig (1973-1976) |
| 3 | John Torbet (1928-1931) |
| 3 | Kenny Chisholm (1946-1946) |
| 3 | Sandy MacLennan (1934-1934) |
| 3 | William Massie (1902-1904) |
| 2 | Alan Archibald (2002-2002) |
| 2 | Alex Younger (1940-1940) |
| 2 | Andy Lyons (1996-1996) |
| 2 | Andy Roxburgh (1965-1966) |
| 2 | Arthur Duncan (1967-1969) |
| 2 | Bill McCrindle (1938-1938) |
| 2 | Bob McFarlane (1921-1922) |
| 2 | Bobby Grove (1924-1932) |
| 2 | Bobby Howitt (1953-1954) |
| 2 | David Alston (1938-1938) |
| 2 | Davie Mathie (1946-1948) |
| 2 | Derek McWilliams (1995-1995) |
| 2 | Donald Park (1979-1983) |
| 2 | George Allan [i] (1897-1897) |
| 2 | Hugh Brown (1945-1946) |
| 2 | Ian Cowan (1963-1963) |
| 2 | Ian Gibson (1977-1980) |
| 2 | Jimmy Gibson (1924-1924) |
| 2 | Liam Lindsay (2016-2017) |
| 2 | Lyle Taylor (2014-2014) |
| 2 | Peter Cunningham (1931-1931) |
| 2 | Peter McKennan (1947-1947) |
| 2 | Robert Conner (1902-1902) |
| 2 | Sammy Picken (1942-1942) |
| 2 | Sandy Brown (1962-1963) |
| 2 | Sandy Hair (1923-1927) |
| 2 | Tom Atherton (1900-1900) |
| 2 | Tom Doonan (1944-1944) |
| 2 | Tommy Rae (1966-1974) |
| 2 | Tony Higgins (1980-1981) |
| 2 | Willie Crawford (1954-1957) |
| 2 | Willie Miller (1934-1935) |
| 2 | Willie Salisbury (1926-1927) |
| 1 | Aaron Muirhead (2013-2013) |
| 1 | Aaron Taylor-Sinclair (2014-2014) |
| 1 | Alan Dinnie (1995-1995) |
| 1 | Alan Hansen (1976-1976) |
| 1 | Alex Glover (1946-1946) |
| 1 | Alex Gourlay (1944-1944) |
| 1 | Alex Hastings (1960-1960) |
| 1 | Alex Lambie (1922-1922) |
| 1 | Allan Alexander (1902-1902) |
| 1 | Andy Thomson (2004-2004) |
| 1 | Angus Stead (1942-1942) |
| 1 | Armand Oné (2005-2005) |
| 1 | Benny Rooney (1975-1975) |
| 1 | Bert Kinnell (1948-1948) |
| 1 | Bill Gray (1906-1906) |
| 1 | Bill Shankly (1944-1944) |
| 1 | Billy Gourlay (1963-1963) |
| 1 | Billy Macdonald (1996-1996) |
| 1 | Blair Spittal (2017-2017) |
| 1 | Bobby Gilmour (1957-1957) |
| 1 | Christie Elliott (2019-2019) |
| 1 | David Melville (1906-1906) |
| 1 | Davie Mathers (1954-1954) |
| 1 | Dougie Wright (1961-1961) |
| 1 | Eddie McLeod (1932-1932) |
| 1 | Gary Fraser (2014-2014) |
| 1 | George Elmore (1911-1911) |
| 1 | George Wyllie (1936-1936) |
| 1 | Harry Gibson (1928-1928) |
| 1 | Harry Wilson (1908-1908) |
| 1 | Iain Jardine (1980-1980) |
| 1 | Ian Cameron [i] (1996-1996) |
| 1 | Ian McIntosh (1957-1957) |
| 1 | Jackie Johnson (1944-1944) |
| 1 | James Kirkland (1898-1898) |
| 1 | Jamie Mitchell (2003-2003) |
| 1 | Jim Fleming (1964-1964) |
| 1 | Jimmy McColl (1922-1922) |
| 1 | Jimmy McDougall (1928-1928) |
| 1 | Joe Hogan (1965-1965) |
| 1 | Joe McBride (1961-1961) |
| 1 | Joe McInnes (1953-1953) |
| 1 | John Bowie (1918-1918) |
| 1 | John Coham (1912-1912) |
| 1 | John Ferguson (1897-1897) |
| 1 | John Flanagan (1969-1969) |
| 1 | John Hansen (1976-1976) |
| 1 | John Muirhead (1903-1903) |
| 1 | Johnny MacKenzie (1956-1956) |
| 1 | Jordan McMillan (2014-2014) |
| 1 | Kallum Higginbotham (2014-2014) |
| 1 | Kenny Watson (1981-1981) |
| 1 | Lee Mair (2014-2014) |
| 1 | Mark Roberts (2006-2006) |
| 1 | Martin Ferguson (1962-1962) |
| 1 | Pat Gallacher (1907-1907) |
| 1 | Ray Farningham (1993-1993) |
| 1 | Ricky Waddell (2003-2003) |
| 1 | Robert Gray (1897-1897)  |
| 1 | Rod McDonald (1995-1995) |
| 1 | Scott McDonald (2019-2019)  |
| 1 | Sean Welsh (2016-2016) |
| 1 | Stephen Docherty (1995-1995) |
| 1 | Steven Lawless (2017-2017) |
| 1 | Stevie Chalmers (1973-1973) |
| 1 | Stevie Pittman (1995-1995) |
| 1 | Tom Callaghan (1910-1910) |
| 1 | Tommy Ledgerwood (1950-1950) |
| 1 | Tommy Turner (1996-1996) |
| 1 | Tommy Wright (1946-1946) |
| 1 | Torry Gillick (1952-1952) |
| 1 | Watty Borthwick (1918-1918) |
| 1 | Willie Bulloch (1912-1912) |
| 1 | Willie Freebairn (1900-1900) |
| 1 | Willie Gardiner (1910-1910) |
| 1 | Willie Hamilton (1911-1911) |
| 1 | Willie Paul (1897-1897) |
| 1 | Willie Whittle (1918-1918) |
| |
| first scorer |
| last scorer |
| hat-trick |
| haul of 4 |
| 2 own goals in total |
| all scorers known |
|
