| vs. East Fife competitive |
 |
| 9 | Alex Wright (1955-1961)  |
| 5 | Gareth Evans (1996-1997) |
| 5 | Jimmy Walker (1950-1953) |
| 5 | Johnny MacKenzie (1952-1955) |
| 4 | Billy Dodds (1987-1987)  |
| 4 | Davie McParland (1954-1960) |
| 4 | Jimmy Bone (1971-1971) |
| 4 | John Torbet (1929-1930) |
| 3 | Brian Graham (2020-2021) |
| 3 | David Moss (1997-1997) |
| 3 | Dougie Somner (1975-1975) |
| 3 | Frank Coulston (1971-1972) |
| 3 | John Simpson (1930-1930) |
| 3 | Kenny Watson (1985-1987) |
| 3 | Neil Harris (1920-1920)  |
| 3 | Willie Sharp (1951-1953) |
| 2 | Alex Rae (1970-1971) |
| 2 | Alex Stott (1949-1951) |
| 2 | Andy Lyons (1997-1997) |
| 2 | Bobby Howitt (1952-1953) |
| 2 | Denis McQuade (1971-1976) |
| 2 | Eddie Gallagher (1987-1987) |
| 2 | Johnny Gibson (1973-1973) |
| 2 | Martin Lauchlan (1998-1998) |
| 2 | Matt Crowe (1955-1955) |
| 2 | Paul Walker (2002-2002) |
| 2 | Robert Dunn (1998-1998) |
| 2 | Ronnie Glavin (1970-1972) |
| 2 | Steve Maskrey (1996-1997) |
| 2 | Tommy Rae (1971-1971) |
| 1 | Alan Dinnie (1996-1996) |
| 1 | Alan Logan (1987-1987) |
| 1 | Alan Morgan (1998-1998) |
| 1 | Alex Elliott (1931-1931) |
| 1 | Andréa M'Buyi-Mutombo (2018-2018) |
| 1 | Andy Kerr (1957-1957) |
| 1 | Archie Turner (1930-1930) |
| 1 | Bobby Grove (1927-1927) |
| 1 | Bobby Houston (1975-1975) |
| 1 | Bobby Lawrie (1971-1971) |
| 1 | Colin West (1986-1986) |
| 1 | David Farrell (1996-1996) |
| 1 | Donald Park (1982-1982) |
| 1 | George Boardman (1930-1930) |
| 1 | George Smith (1957-1957) |
| 1 | Iain Jardine (1982-1982) |
| 1 | Ian McDonald (1985-1985) |
| 1 | Ian McIntosh (1953-1953) |
| 1 | Jimmy Davidson (1955-1955) |
| 1 | Jimmy Mallon (1957-1957) |
| 1 | Jimmy McMullan (1920-1920) |
| 1 | Jimmy Rae (1930-1930) |
| 1 | Joe Carson (1986-1986) |
| 1 | Joe Craig (1975-1975) |
| 1 | Joe McBride (1961-1961) |
| 1 | John Connelly (1987-1987) |
| 1 | John Craig (1976-1976) |
| 1 | John Donnelly (1985-1985) |
| 1 | Kemo Avdiu (1999-1999) |
| 1 | Martin Hardie (2002-2002) |
| 1 | Maurice Johnston (1982-1982) |
| 1 | Neil Duffy (1961-1961) |
| 1 | Norrie McCredie (1953-1953) |
| 1 | Pat Kelly (1985-1985) |
| 1 | Peter Mackie (1987-1987) |
| 1 | Scott Houston (1999-1999) |
| 1 | Scott McLean (2002-2002) |
| 1 | Scott Tiffoney (2021-2021)  |
| 1 | Steven Anderson (2019-2019) |
| 1 | Tommy Wright (1948-1948) |
| 1 | William Fraser (1931-1931) |
| 1 | Willie Crawford (1951-1951) |
| 1 | Willie O'Donnell (1948-1948) |
| |
| first scorer |
| last scorer |
| hat-trick |
| haul of 4 |
| 4 own goals in total |
| all scorers known |
|
