| vs. Cowdenbeath competitive |
 |
| 6 | John Miller (1924-1925)   |
| 5 | Davie Ness (1927-1932) |
| 5 | John Simpson (1929-1931)  |
| 5 | Johnny Ballantyne (1928-1934) |
| 5 | Kris Doolan (2010-2013) |
| 4 | Bobby Grove (1924-1928) |
| 3 | Denis McQuade (1972-1978) |
| 3 | George Smith (1956-1956) |
| 3 | Jimmy Gibson (1925-1926) |
| 3 | Paul Tosh (1999-1999) |
| 3 | Peter McKennan (1939-1946) |
| 3 | Sandy Hair (1927-1927) |
| 3 | Willie Miller (1930-1934) |
| 2 | Aaron Muirhead (2012-2013) |
| 2 | Alex Forsyth (1972-1972) |
| 2 | George Boardman (1932-1932) |
| 2 | George Hunter (1930-1930) |
| 2 | John Torbet (1931-1932) |
| 2 | John Wallace (1939-1939) |
| 2 | Robert Dunn (1999-1999) |
| 2 | Robert Jenkins (1930-1930) |
| 2 | Ronnie Glavin (1972-1972) |
| 2 | Steven Craig (2012-2013) |
| 2 | Tommy Rae (1972-1972) |
| 1 | Alex Elliot (1931-1931) |
| 1 | Alex Gourlay (1946-1946) |
| 1 | Andy S. Gibson (2005-2005) |
| 1 | Archie Turner (1929-1929) |
| 1 | Christie Elliott (2013-2013) |
| 1 | Colin McGlashan (1991-1991) |
| 1 | Connor Murray (2021-2021)  |
| 1 | Conrad Balatoni (2013-2013) |
| 1 | George Shaw (1991-1991) |
| 1 | George Wyllie (1931-1931) |
| 1 | Gordon Rae (1991-1991) |
| 1 | Harry Gibson (1928-1928) |
| 1 | Iain Flannigan (2011-2011) |
| 1 | James Douglas (1939-1939) |
| 1 | Jimmy McDougall (1927-1927) |
| 1 | Liam Buchanan (2010-2010) |
| 1 | Robert Regan (1933-1933) |
| 1 | Sammy Picken (1938-1938) |
| 1 | Shea Gordon (2021-2021) |
| 1 | Stephen McConalogue (2005-2005) |
| 1 | Stephen O'Donnell (2013-2013) |
| 1 | Steven Lawless (2013-2013) |
| 1 | Tommy Ewing (1956-1956) |
| 1 | Willie Salisbury (1928-1928) |
| 1 | Zak Rudden (2021-2021) |
| |
| first scorer |
| last scorer |
| hat-trick |
| glut of 5 |
| 1 own goal in total |
| all scorers known |
|
