 | Goals |
|---|---|
| vs. Cliftonville competitive | |
 | |
| 5 | Willie Paul (1886-1886)   |
| 3 | Jerry Suter (1886-1886)   |
| 1 | Andrew Johnston (1886-1886) |
| 1 | Bob Marshall (1886-1886) |
| 1 | Bob Robertson (1886-1886) |
| first scorer |
| last scorer |
| hat-trick |
| glut of 5 |
| no own goals | |
| all scorers known | |