| vs. Brechin City competitive |
 |
| 4 | Chic Charnley (1990-1994)  |
| 3 | Ian McDonald (1982-1986) |
| 3 | Joe Carson (1985-1987) |
| 3 | John Donnelly (1985-1985) |
| 2 | David Elliot (1990-1991) |
| 2 | Juan Ramón (2004-2004)  |
| 2 | Kenny McDowall (1983-1984) |
| 1 | Alan Logan (1985-1985) |
| 1 | Alex Rae (1971-1971) |
| 1 | Alex Taylor (1994-1994) |
| 1 | Billy Gibson (2004-2004) |
| 1 | Bobby Gibb (1956-1956)  |
| 1 | Colin McGlashan (1990-1990) |
| 1 | Denis McQuade (1971-1971) |
| 1 | Frank Coulston (1971-1971) |
| 1 | George Smith (1956-1956) |
| 1 | Gordon Dalziel (1985-1985) |
| 1 | Gordon Smith (1985-1985) |
| 1 | Grant Tierney (1991-1991) |
| 1 | Isaac English (1990-1990) |
| 1 | Jimmy Bone (1971-1971) |
| 1 | John Buckley (1983-1983) |
| 1 | Johnny Flood (1990-1990) |
| 1 | Kenny Watson (1986-1986) |
| 1 | Paul Donnelly (1985-1985) |
| 1 | Ronnie Glavin (1971-1971) |
| 1 | Tommy Ewing (1956-1956) |
| 1 | Willie Herd (1984-1984) |
| 1 | Willie Jamieson (1994-1994) |
| |
| first scorer |
| last scorer |
| hat-trick |
| no own goals |
| all scorers known |
|
