| vs. Berwick Rangers competitive |
 |
| 4 | Martin Hardie (2000-2002) |
| 3 | Scott McLean (2000-2001) |
| 2 | Albert Craig (1995-1995) |
| 2 | Chris Erskine (2009-2009) |
| 2 | Derek McWilliams (1995-1995) |
| 2 | Frank Coulston (1971-1971) |
| 2 | Jimmy Bone (1971-1971)  |
| 2 | Liam Buchanan (2009-2009) |
| 2 | Paul Cairney (2010-2011)  |
| 1 | Bobby Lawrie (1971-1971) |
| 1 | Bryan Hodge (2009-2009) |
| 1 | Danny Lennon (2001-2001) |
| 1 | David Rowson (2010-2010) |
| 1 | Gary Harkins (2007-2007) |
| 1 | George Shaw (2000-2000) |
| 1 | Harry Curran (1995-1995) |
| 1 | Jamie Buchan (2002-2002) |
| 1 | Murray McDowell (2001-2001) |
| 1 | Paul Di Giacomo (2007-2007) |
| 1 | Paul Keegan (2007-2007) |
| 1 | Rod McDonald (1995-1995) |
| 1 | Stevie Pittman (1995-1995) |
| |
| first scorer |
| last scorer |
| no own goals |
| all scorers known |
|
