| vs. Arbroath competitive |
 |
| 7 | Denis McQuade (1970-1975) |
| 5 | Aidan Fitzpatrick (2022-2024)  |
| 5 | John Wallace (1936-1938) |
| 4 | Jimmy Bone (1968-1971) |
| 4 | Peter McKennan (1936-1938) |
| 4 | Scott McLean (2000-2002) |
| 4 | Brian Graham (2020-2024) |
| 3 | Frank Coulston (1971-1974) |
| 3 | Joe Craig (1974-1975) |
| 3 | Kyle Turner (2022-2023) |
| 3 | Martin Hardie (2000-2002) |
| 3 | Robert Dunn (1998-1999) |
| 3 | Ronnie Glavin (1970-1974) |
| 2 | Alan Archibald (2001-2001) |
| 2 | Arthur Duncan (1969-1969) |
| 2 | Frank Donlevy (1958-1959) |
| 2 | George Smith (1958-1963) |
| 2 | Jim Fleming (1963-1963) |
| 2 | John Hansen (1971-1975) |
| 2 | Paul Walker (2001-2001) |
| 2 | Sandy Brown (1963-1963) |
| 2 | Tomi Adeloye (2024-2024) |
| 2 | Tommy Rae (1972-1974) |
| 2 | Willie O'Donnell (1949-1949) |
| 1 | Alan Morgan (1998-1998) |
| 1 | Albert Craig (2000-2000) |
| 1 | Alex McSpadyen (1937-1937) |
| 1 | Alex Rae (1971-1971) |
| 1 | Alex Wright (1958-1958) |
| 1 | Anton Dowds (2022-2022) |
| 1 | Bobby Lawrie (1971-1971) |
| 1 | Charlie Smith (1971-1971) |
| 1 | Ciaran McKenna (2022-2022) |
| 1 | Cole McKinnon (2022-2022) |
| 1 | Danny Lennon (2000-2000) |
| 1 | David Alston (1938-1938) |
| 1 | Davie McParland (1959-1959) |
| 1 | Derek Fleming (2001-2001) |
| 1 | Donnie McDowell (1973-1973) |
| 1 | Fred Hinchcliffe (1936-1936) |
| 1 | Harry Milne (2022-2022) |
| 1 | Ian Wilson (1959-1959) |
| 1 | Jimmy Walker (1949-1949) |
| 1 | John Flanagan (1968-1968) |
| 1 | Jonny Blom (2000-2000) |
| 1 | Kenny Miller (2019-2020) |
| 1 | Neil Duffy (1963-1963) |
| 1 | Paul Tosh (1998-1998) |
| 1 | Russell Kelly (2000-2000) |
| 1 | Sandy MacLennan (1935-1935)  |
| 1 | Stuart Bannigan (2012-2020) |
| 1 | Tommy Bryce (1998-1998) |
| 1 | William Gray (1937-1937) |
| |
| first scorer |
| last scorer |
| 3 own goals in total |
| all scorers known |
|
