| vs. Alloa Athletic competitive |
 |
| 6 | Frank Coulston (1970-1971) |
| 5 | Maurice Johnston (1983-1983) |
| 4 | Andrew Johnston (1885-1885)  |
| 4 | Bob Robertson (1885-1885) |
| 3 | Alex O'Hara (1982-1983) |
| 3 | Calum Campbell (1989-1990) |
| 3 | Gordon Smith (1985-1986) |
| 3 | Kenny McDowall (1983-1983) |
| 3 | Scott McCulloch (2005-2006) |
| 2 | Billy Gibson (2005-2005) |
| 2 | Blair Spittal (2018-2019) |
| 2 | Graham Dorrans (2005-2005) |
| 2 | Joe Cardle (2019-2019) |
| 2 | John Marshall (1885-1885) |
| 2 | Jukka Santala (2005-2005) |
| 2 | Matt Crowe (1956-1956) |
| 2 | Robert Dunn (1999-1999) |
| 2 | Ronnie Glavin (1971-1971) |
| 2 | Scott McDonald (2019-2019) |
| 2 | Stephen McConalogue (2005-2006) |
| 1 | Alan Morgan (1998-1998) |
| 1 | Bob Marshall (1885-1885) |
| 1 | Brian Graham (2024-2024)  |
| 1 | Charlie Adam (1989-1989) |
| 1 | Charlie Smith (1971-1971) |
| 1 | Craig Flannigan (1998-1998) |
| 1 | Dario Zanatta (2019-2019) |
| 1 | Denis McQuade (1971-1971) |
| 1 | Frank Carlow (1923-1923) |
| 1 | Ian McDonald (1984-1984) |
| 1 | James Gibson (2005-2005) |
| 1 | James Miller (1885-1885) |
| 1 | Jimmy Bone (1971-1971) |
| 1 | John Blair (1923-1923) |
| 1 | Kenny Watson (1983-1983) |
| 1 | Kris Doolan (2018-2018) |
| 1 | Mark Roberts (2006-2006) |
| 1 | Martin Lauchlan (1999-1999) |
| 1 | Paul McKenzie (1985-1985) |
| 1 | Scott Miller (2000-2000) |
| 1 | Stephen Docherty (1999-1999) |
| 1 | Stuart Bannigan (2020-2020) |
| 1 | Willie Herd (1984-1984) |
| |
| last scorer |
| haul of 4 |
| first scorer unknown |
| 5 own goals in total |
| 1 unknown scorer in total |
|
