| 1917-18 competitive |
 |
| 35 | Willie Bulloch (87.5%) |
| 34 | Jimmy McMullan (85%) |
| 34 | Tom Adams (85%) |
| 32 | Willie Hamilton (80%) |
| 31 | Willie Whittle (77.5%) |
| 30 | John Bowie (75%) |
| 29 | John King (72.5%) |
| 28 | Jim Marshall (70%) |
| 25 | James Gray (62.5%) |
| 25 | Jim Ferguson (62.5%) |
| 24 | Neil Harris (60%) |
| 19 | Adam Black (47.5%) |
| 18 | Joe Harris (45%) |
| 15 | Robert Bruce (37.5%) |
| 14 | John McEwan (35%) |
| 11 | Archie Maclachlan (27.5%) |
| 10 | Robert Sibbald (25%) |
| 9 | William Reid [ii] (22.5%) |
| 6 | Brough Fletcher (15%) |
| 5 | James Gardiner (12.5%) |
| 3 | Stan Seymour (7.5%) |
| 1 | Bob McGrory (2.5%) |
| 1 | McDonald (2.5%) |
| 1 | Smith [ii] (2.5%) |
| |
| showing appearances % |
|
